I ran across something of a barbecue conundrum while driving around the Mid-Cities the other day. There are two barbecue “barns” right down the street from each other. I thought it was a glitch in the Matrix, or maybe the North Richland Hills-Colleyville city boundary was like the barbecue Mason-Dixon line.

I imagined the two as rivals, engaging in all sorts of fraternity prank-esque hijinks. … no, stop with the invented drama. For Pete’s sake, I thought, just go eat there. So I did — I went barnstorming, you might say, to settle once and for all which one is better.

The Red Barn Bar-B-Que (4913 Colleyville Blvd., Colleyville) just looks like my kind of place. Inside, it has that bait-and-tackle-store aesthetic. Outside it’s red and planked — you know, barn-y. It’s a pretty simple operation. Everything is served on paper or in Styrofoam, and you go through a line to order.


On a recent weekday lunch hour, the line wasn’t long, and my guest and I were served by two very nice young fellas who weren’t in any particular hurry. But I was, as was my guest, so we were off to a bad start.

The pork ribs on my ribs plate ($11.99) had a subtle smoky flavor but no crispness, and they weren’t quite falling off the bone — more like sagging on the bone. Both the spicy and the sweet sauces tasted vinegary, although the spicy version had a nice kick. The accompanying onion rings and coleslaw were good, not great. The chopped brisket sandwich ($8.99) was tender, albeit a little bland. The potato salad was really tangy, but very heavy on the mayo. All in all, I gave it a definite meh.

In the other corner is the Big Barn BBQ (8021 Main St. NRH). My guest and I were met in the parking lot by the manager, who informed us we could eat there. Say what? After a who’s-on-first routine, he explained that the restaurant had just expanded its hours to what it says they are on its website. Translation: Technically they were open but trying to close, and the quicker he could feed us and get rid of us, the better.

As it turned out, the quasi-bum’s rush wasn’t a bad deal for us. The interior is pretty standard-issue barbecue joint, but the weather was nice, the patio is big and welcoming, and we had it to ourselves for a while.

The meat selection was vast, as was my appetite. I went for the double meat plate ($12.49), with jalapeño-cheddar sausage and chopped brisket. Both were outstanding, and the spicy barbecue sauce had a nice zing. The accompanying sides — fried okra and hand-cut fries — were decent if not spectacular. I was completely out-ordered by my friend, who went for the fall-off-the-bone crispy ribs and big-as-a-football smoked chicken, with a nice peppery rub. The chipotle chicken macaroni salad, fresh and zesty, won the Best in Show for both eateries.

Turned out, the battle of the barns was barely even a fair fight. Big Barn won, plates down. It also helps that they serve alcohol and have a nice patio, and Red Barn offers neither.

Now that that’s settled, I’m off to mediate a dispute among several restaurants with “Mamma” in the name, to see who has the superior female progenitor. Or maybe just better comfort food.

Previous articleRotten Roots Jam
Next articleQuaker City Live