Fort Worth Weekly - News, Entertainment, Restaurants, Music

Home News Cover Story Sacrificed to Shale

Sacrificed to Shale

E-mail Print PDF
Comments
Add New Search
+/-
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Subject:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
Paul  - Good article.   |168.38.111.xxx |2009-10-14 07:54:31
Excellent article. Thorough and well-thought out.
Sharon Ward  - Sacrificed to Big Oil & Gas   |75.106.38.xxx |2009-10-14 09:10:54
This article dares to tell truths about
Corporate abuse.Failure of TCEQ &
TRC
to protect people from it. In our
County, people are afraid, or too
bamboozled
to speak up,as many are
employed by, or receive "mailbox
money"
(leases) from industry.We
too wanted to retire here,before we were completely
surrounded by gas
wells, pipelines, and compressor
stations.Texas was given
the authority
to enact a Noise Law in 1982, but that
would co$t industry for
abatement.
Freestone County = 130 compressors
splashdown!  - sacrificed to shale   |74.47.92.xxx |2009-10-14 11:37:13
The energy crisis facing our nation has many facets. One that has been
downplayed by the oil and gas industry, regulatory governmental overseers, and
hopeful leaseholders, for obvious rea$ons, is the enormous cost in terms of
individual, public and environmental safety, health and well-being. However,
things are beginning to change. The toxic damage being done can no longer be
minimized or brushed aside. Awareness is growing and concern is mounting.
Peter
Gorman's "Sacrificed to Shale", is an excellent, comprehensive exposé,
giving us a close up look at the health, safety and quality of life concerns
facing the people of DISH,TX on almost every level.
It's a major heads up for
people living on top of shale everywhere. Thank you FW Weekly for being
outspoken on this hugely important issue! Nice job Peter Gorman!
Anonymous  - Good Article   |64.12.116.xxx |2009-10-14 12:02:49
Excellent article. Anyone that doesn't believe this stuff is going on, just
needs to move to a stinking, sour gas field in Texas. Go live there, and then
tell us how wonderful it is--O&G operator, landman, O&G PR person, Bought off
politician, etc.
charlie murphy  - The Good Neighbor Altar   |173.97.77.xxx |2009-10-14 12:06:52
As City after City is laid on the Altar of the Gas Industry, their “Good
Neighbor” promise will begin to run with the “blood” of everyday, good
hearted, trusting Americans. Fresh offerings are the duty of the TCEQ and TRC.
They perform their duty with the enthusiasm of a gladiator yearning to prove his
worth with “acceptable” sacrifices – our homes and neighborhoods and
communities.

We have returned to feudal times, and Dish, Texas while putting
up a valiant fight is slowly being drug to Altar. However, their
“sacrifice” is not yet complete. The contamination of their air must be
followed by the contamination of their water, and finally, “unexpected”
explosions. Only then will the Gas Industry see this as a total VICTORY.
Sharon Wilson  - great comment   |72.48.170.xxx |2009-10-14 13:01:21
Charlie
damayor  - Not without a fight   |67.210.159.xxx |2009-10-14 15:19:12
Sorry Charlie, we are not going down without a fight. The compare this to David
vs Goliath, but remember...David won.
charlie murphy  - For sure   |66.14.121.xxx |2009-10-15 02:22:31
I have nothing but admiration for the incredible effort that Dish, Texas has put
forth to defeat the lies, deceit and arrogance of an industry that revels in
destroying what good people have worked hard to achieve. I believe that you
have become the symbol of what good leadership should mean in this country.
Sharon Wilson  - I'm standing with   |129.120.106.xxx |2009-10-15 02:27:45
damayor!
Tammi   |205.188.117.xxx |2009-10-22 07:40:31
That is right! Small but mighty!!!
Anonymous  - Dish Texas   |64.12.116.xxx |2009-10-14 12:13:05
They ought to sell the RRC off at public auction. Maybe keep the maping
activity which sort of tells us where the wells are. As far as the TCEQ, just
go to Austin and padlock the doors--send the employees home. The TCEQ doesn't
even map where the emission sources are located in Texas!! That agency is of no
help to the ordinary citizen.
Sharon Wilson  - Additional information just released   |72.48.170.xxx |2009-10-14 12:58:02
Additional lab results have just been released from the DISH, TX ambient air
quality study. http://txsharon.blogspot.com/2009/10/breaking-meth
ane-3-times-higher-than.html *Methane was present at a level three times higher
than normally found in the air.* Methane, the most powerful GHG, is 20 times
more powerful at heating our atmosphere than CO2. It is highly flammable and an
asphyxiant.

Thank you to Peter Gorman and Jeff Prince for telling the very
personal stories of the Victims of the Shale. Thank you to the FW Weekly for
printing these stories.

Everyone needs to understand 3 things:
1. DISH is not
the only area affected. There are many areas and individuals who's health and
property have been damaged.
2. The oil & gas industry enjoys broad exemptions
from every one of our federal environmental statutes. We are currently working
to overturn a Cheney-era exemption from the Safe Drinking Water Act. Please ask
our Cong...
Sharon Wilson  - continued   |72.48.170.xxx |2009-10-14 13:00:28
Please ask your Congressional representative to support the FRAC Act. If your
representative won't, find one who will.
3. How is it moral for a some people to
be so horribly harmed both financially and physically so that we can continue
our addiction to dirty fossil fuels?

Actually there are more than 3 things but
these 3 are critical.
Susan Wallace-Babb  - Sacrificed to Big Oil&Gas   |69.46.58.xxx |2009-10-14 13:37:07
Excellent article! This shows exactly what is happening where oil/gas
exploration and extraction is going on in this country.
I experienced this same
scenario in Parachute, CO from '03-'06 when I was finally unable to breathe the
air in the home I had lived in for 10 years. I am now multiple chemical
sensitive (MCS) and completely disabled due to walking into a toxic cloud of
condensate tank emissions. It happened in a second and the long term damage is
yet to be known.
If you can't believe this article please think again. All of
this is the absolute truth especially the information regarding the exemption
from all EPA regulations for anything having to do with oil/gas exploration and
extraction. This industry will kill anyone with OUR government's tacit
approval. Run for your lives if you are able. Oil/gas industry will sacrifice
any and all in the way of their Almighty Dollar worship.
charlie murphy  - Thanks for speaking out   |173.97.77.xxx |2009-10-14 14:35:56
Very sorry to read about your loss of good health. A very compelling story -
indeed.
Cheap Tricks and Costly Truths  - Apalling   |75.36.99.xxx |2009-10-14 13:46:32
What a compelling article. I've just finished reading the emissions report and
what's the craziest thing, is that the combustion engines can be easily phased
to electric at a savings! I just can't believe the irresponsibility and
smugness of the oil and gas industry. I feel for DISH, we experience a fire out
here in Wink every single time there's lightning. This morning at 2AM, I was
awoken again by a very bad sweet smell. I used to think it was the skunks, but
now I know better.
Anonymous  - Sweet Smell   |205.188.117.xxx |2009-10-14 14:52:38
Same thing in Booger County--lots of compressors without permits or
registrations--nobody gives a damn! Big Gas is in control. Also a lot of that
'sweet' smell. Permits say they are using odorant to squash smell of H2S but
they don't take a reduction for this action. Also many other bad smells, all
kind sof sulfur including combusiton fumes, etc. It's eveywhere in Texas. Want
gas--better run from Texas!
damayor  - Thanks Peter   |67.210.159.xxx |2009-10-14 13:50:10
We need more who tell the real story, no matter how disturbing it may be.
Jerry Lobdill  - Sacrificed to Shale   |99.19.0.xxx |2009-10-14 16:00:42
This is absolutely the very best article I have ever read on this predatory
industry.

And to think that a proper response to this rape would come from
little DISH instead of Fort Worth!!

Fort Worth is going down big time.

Thanks
FW Weekly and Peter Gorman!!!!
Gary Hogan  - Calvin Tillman& their small council are courageous   |70.254.164.xxx |2009-10-14 18:51:20
Calvin Tillman& their small council are courageous unlike those that seem to sit
guard over the interests of O & G in Fort Worth Texas. Note their first response
to an independent study is to help refute the findings rather than initiate
their own study to say ghee We need to know what all this activity is doing to
OUR citizens. After all we have 32 compressor stations in a much more densely
populated area. But we are to afraid to not upset the O & G industry. Oh they
might leave and the BOON might be over. Well the BOOM maybe yet to come for
Fort Worth. We even plan to build a new Elementary School in the shadow of a 14
multiple well site ( check the facts it's not 6 ) In spite of the fact that it
should be 600 ft from the boundary of the pad site isn't 600 ft from a well bore
OK ? FWISD asked and gotr 600 ft from the boundary of their FWISD school
properties but then says OK to a less distance at AUSSIE and this proposal....
Laura P  - thanks, Peter   |75.100.59.xxx |2009-10-15 02:49:34
Great article, Peter. Thanks for your hard work and courage to tell an important
story. Where are the regulators? Why the lack of public education on the issue?
Why are citizens so uninformed? I've been posting and forwarding this article
far and wide in the hopes that people understand that natural gas isn't the
clean fuel industry would have everyone believe. And seriously, where are the
regulators on this issue?
charlie murphy  - The word is "BRIBE"   |66.14.121.xxx |2009-10-15 05:01:24
Busy taking campaign contributions and finding out EXACTLY what will make the
gas industry happy.
Anonymous  - Sacrificed to Big Oil & Gas   |151.142.239.xxx |2009-10-15 07:05:24
Please take a moment an review the science used in this study; where are the
samples collected in areas not near the gas sites? What else produces methane?
Sounds like a targeted study not a true scientific analysis. You may also want
to look at what so call standards they are refering too and how those standards
are defined.
Anonymous  - Sacrificed to Big Oil & Gas   |151.142.239.xxx |2009-10-15 07:22:27
Correlation and causation are not the same. Just because there are gas
compressors in the area and elevated concentrations were measured does not mean
A causes B. Maybe the gas compressors caused it, but maybe not. This study
doesn't prove a link, just that additional investigation is needed. There are
several roads in the area, trucking company, airport, agriculture, etc. Or air
could have blown in from elsewhere.
Sharon Wilson  - Have you ever been to DISH?   |129.120.106.xxx |2009-10-15 10:21:47
There is FM 156 which has some traffic but it's a FM road so the traffic is not
heavy. The rest of the roads are very small roads with little traffic.

The
airport has an average of 2 take-offs or landings per week.

Nice try, but there
is no other industry in DISH or around DISH.
Anonymous   |71.164.148.xxx |2009-10-15 13:32:01
The fact that the road is an "FM" tells us nothing about the traffic
flow. FM 157 is a heavily travelled road through Arlington. The way to answer
this question is with traffic counts not subjective opinions. TCEQ is studying
elevated air pollutant concentrations:
http://www.tceq.state.tx.us/implementation/tox/res earch/roadways.html

Does
FM 156 traffic cause or contribute to the measured concentrations in DISH? We
don't know. Again, the study did not establish cause.

There is a trucking
yard called Louisiana near the monitor locations also. Did it cause or
contribute? We don't know.
Sharon Wilson  - See my comment below   |72.48.170.xxx |2009-10-15 14:45:19
regarding the infrared camera. It's hard to dispute hard evidence like that.
Several saw the same thing.Industry only wants to continue their polluting ways.


You are stretching the first myth of toxicology to the limit. There comes a
point when reasonable people have to use reason. It is most reasonable to
believe that the only industrial plant in the vicinity is the culprit. It is
most prudent to protect the citizens of DISH. When did industry gain more rights
than people who need protection? Your position is ridiculous.
Please see:
http://txsharon.blogspot.com/2009/10/seeing-methan e-leaks-through-infrared.html
Anonymous  - What are TCEQ ESLs?   |151.142.239.xxx |2009-10-16 02:45:46
Straight from the TCEQ website
http://www.tceq.state.tx.us/implementation/tox/esl /ESLMain.html

Note these
are screening levels not standards. This is why more study is needed before
drastic action is taken

Effects Screening Levels are used to evaluate the
potential for effects to occur as a result of exposure to concentrations of
constituents in the air. ESLs are based on data concerning health effects, the
potential for odors to be a nuisance, effects on vegetation, and corrosive
effects. They are not ambient air standards. If predicted or measured airborne
levels of a constituent do not exceed the screening level, adverse health or
welfare effects are not expected. If ambient levels of constituents in air
exceed the screening levels, it does not necessarily indicate a problem but
rather triggers a review in more depth.
Sharon Wilson  - blah, blah, blah,   |129.120.106.xxx |2009-10-16 09:25:04
The same old industry BS. Here's how it goes:
Water is fine and drinkable.
Fracking occurs and suddenly water is contaminated. Tests reveal drilling
chemicals in water. Industry says there is no proof fracking caused the
contamination. No matter that the pattern follows hundreds of cases all across
the nation.

Air is fine, trees grow, horses thrive. Compressor station is
installed. Air turns bad, trees die and so do horses. Tests find drilling
related toxins in the air. Video show leaking VOCs. Industry claims no proof,
tests not conclusive.

Its a stalling tactic and the burden of proof is way to
high.
Sharon Wilson  - Methane leaks seen with infrafed video   |72.48.170.xxx |2009-10-15 07:49:35
This should drive a stake right into the heart of the "clean" energy
myth. Internationally, the amount of methane escaping from gas and oil
operations can be only crudely gauged. But in 2006 the E.P.A. estimated that
Russia, the world’s largest gas producer, ranked highest, with 427 billion
cubic feet of methane escaping annually, followed by the United States at 346
billion, Ukraine at 225 billion and Mexico at 191 billion.
But the EPA estimates
that the figure is much higher:: 8 million cars
worth.
http://txsharon.blogspot.com/2009/10/seeing
-methane-leaks-through-infrared.html
Sharon Ward  - Sacrificed To Big Oil & Gas   |75.106.38.xxx |2009-10-15 09:03:47
Typical, blame it on something else.
Roads, trucks, airport,
agriculture,
blown in from somewhere else. Is
that your best defense?
Documentation,
Documentation,Documentation. Where's
your paperwork?
Anonymous  - Sacrificed To Big Oil & Gas   |151.142.239.xxx |2009-10-15 09:38:45
Sharon, you misunderstood the comment. I didn't say blame roads, trucks,
airport, agriculture, or wind. Rather, these are all possible contributors to
the measured concentrations. It is very important to note the DISH study only
measured air concentrations. It did not determine what caused the
concentrations. Yes, there are compressors in the area, but there are also other
air emissions sources in the immediate area. The causes need to be clearly
established before fingers are pointed. Here is a wikipedia link to help:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_ imply_causation
Get Informed!!!  - Sacrificed To Big Oil & Gas   |151.142.239.xxx |2009-10-15 09:47:42
True Documentation,I don't see enough to point a finger so quickly; this was a
1 day 24hr sample out of 365 days, with no background or ambient information for
the area. Also what is a TCEQ ESL. Is it really a standard. Maybe someone who
understands all this information needs to chime in.
Rick Perry  - Sacrificed To Big Oil & Gas   |151.142.239.xxx |2009-10-15 09:52:28
Good Point. If I judged the year-round weather in Texas from just one day, I
might conclude it is always really hot or always really cold.
Anonymous  - Reply to Rick Perry   |172.129.131.xxx |2009-10-15 12:45:53
The Guv is real pollution friendly!!!
How close to a compressor station does
the Guv live???
Rick Perry  - Reply to Rick Perry   |151.142.239.xxx |2009-10-16 07:11:37
I use crude oil as hair styling gel!
Sharon Wilson  - Anonymous poster   |72.48.170.xxx |2009-10-15 14:33:18
I was in DISH Monday where we were treated to a demonstration of a Flir
GasFinder video camera. When we looked through that camera we saw copious
amounts of "black smoke" which are really VOCs boiling out of the areas
marked on the photographs posted here:
http://txsharon.blogspot.com/2009/10/seeing-methan
e-leaks-through-infrared.html
No matter how hard we looked, we didn't see that
same "black smoke" anywhere else in DISH.
Tim Ruggiero  - Desparate for Gas   |76.0.111.xxx |2009-10-15 10:39:24
When did we become so desperate for natural gas that poisoning our children
became an acceptable risk?

Aruba Petroleum showed up on my property 2 weeks
ago, destroyed a $15,000 fence and rendered useless a barn that we spent $9,000
on, and now we have a gas rig, mobile homes, camper trailers, satellite dishes,
bulldozers and other assorted equipment right in what was my horse pasture.

I'm
now paying someone else $1000 a month to board my horses because I don't have
any pasture area left for them.

We're now contending with a massive diesel
generator that pumps massive plumes of exhaust into the air-sometime towards the
house wind depending-every 3-4 minutes, 24/7.

We've lost 20% of the value of
our property- so far. It's not going to get better.

Today, I was told that
they now want to run a gas line through the other part of my property. "If I
say 'No' I asked?". "They'll just do it anyway", said he
r...
Sharon Ward  - Scacrificed To Big Oil & Gas   |75.106.38.xxx |2009-10-15 10:50:34
ANNONYMOUS: Yes, cow poots are
methane, but, cows have been pooting
around
without killing trees for a long
time.I don't point, was taught it is
rude.
Only ask for Golden Rule which is
forgotten all too often, with big Oil
&
Ga$.
Sharon Wilson  - The American Cattle Raisers Assoc   |72.48.170.xxx |2009-10-15 14:36:09
did some research and found that changing the diet of the cattle reduces methane
production dramatically. They are recommending that all cattle raisers make the
adjustments in their bovine's diet.
Anonymous  - Pooting   |205.188.117.xxx |2009-10-15 15:21:13
Human farts have H2S and methane in them. O&G rational is that since your farts
have bad gas, it must be your fault. All other emissions of methane pale in
volume when compared to the methane released due to O&G drilling and production.
You bet!
Look before you leap!  - Methane   |151.142.239.xxx |2009-10-16 03:48:35
Over 95% of methane and other green house gases are released into the
environment from natural sources including plant decay. All industry your
electric company, your cars and your trash contribute only contributes 5%.
Control your own emissions!!
Anonymous  - BS   |205.188.117.xxx |2009-10-16 07:33:35
And you are saying nothing from O&G??? WAJ. There is NO required reporting of
emissions of greenhouse gasses from O&G drilling and production!!! Therefore
you're clean--You think I'm gonna believe that? Excellent PR on your part
Anonymous  - Big Oil   |205.188.117.xxx |2009-10-16 07:39:10
95% of what is reported--and you don't report. Good work Big Gas!
Mike H.  - shale gas scarifice   |76.126.99.xxx |2009-10-23 13:00:13
Some substance that are used in the fracing fluid for gas shale are quite
dangerous, like organophosphates, plus other substances with serious health
questions, like glycols. And, the gas wells yield hydrogen sulfide (H2S) &
carbon disulfide (CS2), which are not always checked for in areas around gas
wells.

I really doubt these cattle kills are from cattle flatulence! And, trees
dying recently? Did the drillers high a tree surgeon to find out what killed the
trees?

I guess Rachel Carson wasn't an enviro wacko in "Silent Spring".
Fort Worth Loser  - Rights Abuse in Texas   |32.145.100.xxx |2009-11-03 05:54:53
This story clearly illustrates the unbelievable, and another grandiose hypocrisy
of the American system. The principle of property ownership is a farce in
Texas, there is no such thing, it's only temporary. What is taking place all
over Barnett land is no different than the abusive governments of countries in
South America, Africa and Asia. So what makes America different when it's
people are equal losers.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 

The Blotch Blog



Destination: Snook

Destination: Snook Chow, Baby is rushing the roadtrip season a bit, but you know, sometimes you just get in the mood to accidentally leave your CD case on the dining room table on y...
More:

Rahr-garitaville

Rahr-garitaville A long time ago, I used to really like Jack Johnson . And Sublime . And Bob Marley . In fact, if there's a band you can associate with drunk dudes in college, it may ...
More:

Film Shorts

Film Shorts OPENING: An Education (PG-13) This radiant and gently heartbreaking drama is one of 2009's best movies. The Oscar-nominated Carey Mulligan stars as a 16-year-old ...
More:

More Hell to Pay

To the editor : Thank you for reporting on the payroll audit mess at the Fort Worth school district ("Payroll Hell," Jan. 20, 2010). It's not over, unfortunately...
More: